Eataly

  • 4.19
  • Superb!
  • Food:4.2
  • Decor:3.4
  • Service:3.6

200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010New York / Manhattan / Flatiron  [ Map ]

(212) 229-2560  [ Website ]

Italian / Cafes$20 - $29

Today: 

Write a Review
Write your review for Eataly!

×

Add a Blog

Reviews of Eataly  (490)

Featured Review

    • 4.0

Eataly

I finally made it to the Nutella bar at Eataly, the fantastic market place located close to the Flatiron. And I did not regret it! If you are a Nutella lover, this place is for you and, for sure, you will not know what to get, the choices all looking good.

Eataly

Eataly

I was there after lunch and so got my espresso (I am addicted to coffee). But it was not your regular espresso: it was topped with a delicious homemade whipped cream and some Nutella.
Eataly

Eataly

With it, I chose the bombolone, an Italian beignet that was also filled with a generous amount of Nutella (although there is never enough). It was a large beignet, well made, being not heavy and airy.
Eataly

Eataly

Eataly

For a first...Read more at: http://www.ijustwanttoeat.com/post/review/eataly-nutella-bar-italian-nyc-ny

  •  753016
  •  753017
  •  753018
  •  753019
  •  753020
  •  753021
  •  753022
  •  753023

Two Incredible Reds from Andrea Scovero

I had the incredible pleasure of meeting Andrea Scovero at Eataly last month; a winemaker known for his dedication to crafting small production wines completely by hand and focusing on the nature of the land to "paint" and create.   

Eataly

All of his wines are lovely but I suggest Barbera D'Asti Ciapin; the late harvest grapes create bold dark fruit flavors that are incredibly lush or the Il Clown Nebbiolo; a favorite of the world's best restaurants like Copenhagen's Noma for its powerful yet elegant body and distinct floral flavor. These slightly esoteric wines are a true delight to find- Salute!

 

  •  677749

Eataly: Antipasto

    • 4.5
  • Food: 5.0
  • Decor: 4.0
  • Service: 4.5

I had waited to return a couple other times to give you a more through assessment of Eataly. Fantastic place to learn, indulge, and entertain guests away from home. Each section is cleverly sectioned into different themes. Dessert tiramisu and a caffe mocha, the first time. Upon return had a plate of prosciutto and mozzarella paired with a white wine. An amazing array of wine choices span their menu... despite being packed most of the time, it maintains it's charm.

  • prosciutto, mozzerella, wine 151350

Eataly

    • 3.0

This place is so fun when you want foods from Italy.

I've chosen seafoods, ordered salmon in medium by grilled.
Eecause I was in little rush to go back the office, brought back desserts to eat at desk. As it was small...I should have brought couple of more.

  •  741801

Eataly

    • 3.8

I had prosciutto, ham, salami & cheese plate. It came with slice of bread. I also had burrata cheese, my favorite :) 

Very fresh and good. 
While we are eating, commercial shooting has started with The sopranos 's actors :) 
  •  746990
  •  746991
  •  746992

Eataly NYC

This glorious #CaesarSalad adds 18-month #GranaPadano +  friulano to the standard , , , , , wine  &

This glorious #CaesarSalad adds 18-month #GranaPadano + friulano to the standard , , , , , wine & olive oil. It's not just the flavor either: "I want it to look nice," says lidiabastianich, halting a server to adjust. She taught us about first - and still does it best. Fun, food! #GatherWithGrana

  • This glorious #CaesarSalad adds 18-month #GranaPadano +  friulano to the standard , , , , , wine  &  270231

Eataly NYC

Check out this Espresso at Eataly NYC eatalyusa   // Thx fredwilson for the rec!

Check out this Espresso at Eataly NYC eatalyusa // Thx fredwilson for the rec!

Check out this Polpo alla Griglia (Grilled Octopus, Salsa Verde, Olives) at Il Pesce  Eataly eatalyu

Check out this Polpo alla Griglia (Grilled Octopus, Salsa Verde, Olives) at Il Pesce Eataly eatalyusa // Sizable portion for $21. Not the best but the olives were interesting

Check out this Orata alla Griglia (Grilled Whole Fish) at Il Pesce  Eataly eatalyusa   // Our waiter

Check out this Orata alla Griglia (Grilled Whole Fish) at Il Pesce Eataly eatalyusa // Our waiter's fave - that's where we went wrong

Check out these Baby Carrots (Seasonal Vegetables) at Il Pesce  Eataly eatalyusa   #GoodEatsOrganize

Check out these Baby Carrots (Seasonal Vegetables) at Il Pesce Eataly eatalyusa #GoodEatsOrganized

  • Check out this Espresso at Eataly NYC eatalyusa   // Thx fredwilson for the rec! 528435
  • Check out this Polpo alla Griglia (Grilled Octopus, Salsa Verde, Olives) at Il Pesce  Eataly eatalyu 528436
  • Check out this Orata alla Griglia (Grilled Whole Fish) at Il Pesce  Eataly eatalyusa   // Our waiter 528437
  • Check out these Baby Carrots (Seasonal Vegetables) at Il Pesce  Eataly eatalyusa   #GoodEatsOrganize 528440

Eataly NYC

    • 4.5

Switching to #RedWine for the #PizzaFritta and #Arancini at eatalyusa with vickisee #Delicioso #Frie

Switching to #RedWine for the #PizzaFritta and #Arancini at eatalyusa with vickisee #Delicioso #FriedPizza #HousemadeMozzarella #Basil #RiceBalls #Saffron #GranaPadano #LemonAoli #Eataly #NYC #AllWeDoIsEat

  • Switching to #RedWine for the #PizzaFritta and #Arancini at eatalyusa with vickisee #Delicioso #Frie 527016
  •  535223
  •  535224
  •  535225
  •  535226
  •  535227
  •  535228
  •  535229
  •  535230
  •  535231

I love Eataly, the bustling Italian marketplace located across the Flatiron. The last time we ended up there was for pizza, at their restaurant La Pizza & La Pasta. We went early enough, right before they opened for service, to get a table as this place can be crazy.
Eataly

Eataly

I like this place: low key, you definitely go there more for the food than for the decor. Menu wise, we were more focused on the pizza than the pasta, although I eyed the linguine con vongole, my favorite. We decided to order two pizzas:

The quattro formaggi or four cheese pizza, made with mozzarella, gorgonzola, parmigiano reggiano and pecorino romano (there is no tomato sauce):
Eataly

Eataly

The second one was the calzone, made with ricotta, mozzarella, tomato sauce and prosciutto cotto:
Eataly

Eataly

The quattro formaggi was delicious, perfect for cheese lovers as they are generous with the quantity of cheese they put on top. I also loved the crust that was thin in the center and puffed up on the outside, with a nice char and crunchiness. I retrieved these characteristics with the calzone that was different from the one I am used to and was in fact my favorite. I loved the fact that they put some tomato sauce on the outside and the ricotta definitely tamed down the saltiness of the prosciutto. This is really a dish I recommend.
Eataly

Eataly

I should mention that, similar to the other restaurants at Eataly, they brought us some bread and olive oil at the beginning of the meal: bad idea as I could not stop eating it...

Although it is a...Read more at: http://www.ijustwanttoeat.com/post/2015/3/29/la-pizza-pasta-eataly-new-york-ny

  •  524086
  •  524087
  •  524088
  •  524089
  •  524090
  •  524091
  •  524092
  •  524093
  •  524094

Eataly NYC

The FRU FRU makes me happy!  eatalyusa #NYC Oval Shaped 3-Part Pizza: 1/3 Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella
a

The FRU FRU makes me happy! eatalyusa #NYC Oval Shaped 3-Part Pizza: 1/3 Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella and Fresh Basil, 1/3 Mozzarella, Prosciutto di Parma, Arugula and Grana Padano, 1/3 Mozzarella, Ricotta and Prosciutto Cotto. When is Eataly opening in Miami again? #NYCtoMIA

  • The FRU FRU makes me happy!  eatalyusa #NYC Oval Shaped 3-Part Pizza: 1/3 Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella
a 217996

Eataly NYC

    • 4.5

A nice hearty lunch at  - one of my favorite store and restaurant in the city. It's like going to It

A nice hearty lunch at - one of my favorite store and restaurant in the city. It's like going to Italy without having to fly to Italy. This over 10,000SF store now has a roof top restaurant as well. There are specialty restaurants within this store.

  • A nice hearty lunch at  - one of my favorite store and restaurant in the city. It's like going to It 517767

Eataly NYC

Your lunch should start with a visit to a napoletana pizza topped with fresh mozzarella , oregano ,

Your lunch should start with a visit to a napoletana pizza topped with fresh mozzarella , oregano , olives and fresh basil .. A quick touch of spicy olive oil drizzle to elevate all the ingredients . Happy eating --

  • Your lunch should start with a visit to a napoletana pizza topped with fresh mozzarella , oregano ,  526449

Eataly NYC

If you still need an excuse to take advantage of white truffle season, check out eatalyusa today whe

If you still need an excuse to take advantage of white truffle season, check out eatalyusa today where they're hosting #TruffleDay by selling all their urbanitruffles to take home AT COST Otherwise, I recommend getting it shaved over dishes like this delicious fazzoletti with chicken ragu from their #IlTartufo truffle pop-up restaurant

  • If you still need an excuse to take advantage of white truffle season, check out eatalyusa today whe 302514

Eataly NYC

Eataly has a saying: "Nutella goes with everything" and I am inclined to agree Sweet Milk's Gelato t

Eataly has a saying: "Nutella goes with everything" and I am inclined to agree Sweet Milk's Gelato topped with #Nutella with a fresh #Croissant filled with Nutella...because I can never have enough nyc

  • Eataly has a saying: "Nutella goes with everything" and I am inclined to agree Sweet Milk's Gelato t 451408

Eataly NYC

An aphrodisiac for sure -- fell in love with the summer vibes last night at the press preview of eat

An aphrodisiac for sure -- fell in love with the summer vibes last night at the press preview of eatalyusa's #Sabbia on the roof, which officially opens to the public tonight at 5 for the season nyc #SeasideAtSabbia

  • An aphrodisiac for sure -- fell in love with the summer vibes last night at the press preview of eat 668935

Eataly NYC

Vacationing in Eataly for the afternoon  #EEEEEATS  Xsarsaysso

Vacationing in Eataly for the afternoon #EEEEEATS Xsarsaysso

When you take an awesome photo of your pistachio & the girl photobombing your pic out does you    #E

When you take an awesome photo of your pistachio & the girl photobombing your pic out does you #EEEEEATS #InfatuationSummer food

  • Vacationing in Eataly for the afternoon  #EEEEEATS  Xsarsaysso 281101
  • When you take an awesome photo of your pistachio & the girl photobombing your pic out does you    #E 281102

Eataly NYC

You guys there is an all vegetarian restaurant at eatalyusa! Feasting like queens with my partner in

You guys there is an all vegetarian restaurant at eatalyusa! Feasting like queens with my partner in foodie crime, rossellarago. Of course, I had to try out the brussel sprout salad with pine nuts immediately, it was delicious and so were the other three dishes we ordered and the bonus cauliflower app we got by happy accident! #letfoodLIGHTyouup

  • You guys there is an all vegetarian restaurant at eatalyusa! Feasting like queens with my partner in 424505

Nutella Bar - Eataly NYC

It's never too late to try the awesome Nutella Bar in NYC's eatalyusa this Nutella Waffle was superb

It's never too late to try the awesome Nutella Bar in NYC's eatalyusa this Nutella Waffle was superb! -----------------------------------------------Nunca es demasiado tarde para probar el bar de Nutella en Eataly NYC, este waffle de Nutella estuvo espectacular!!

  • It's never too late to try the awesome Nutella Bar in NYC's eatalyusa this Nutella Waffle was superb 358126

Nutella Bar - Eataly NYC

This spout spits out Nutella. 'Nuff said. #EEEEEATS #DessertGram #Chocolate #Nutella #Delicious #Eat

This spout spits out Nutella. 'Nuff said. #EEEEEATS #DessertGram #Chocolate #Nutella #Delicious #Eats #NYCFood #NYCFoodie #NutellaLove #NutellaLover #Dessert #iPhone #iPhoneCamera #Crepes #Foodgram #NYCGram #FoodPhotography #NYC #Eataly

#Crepes #Eataly #Foodie #Foodgram #Foodstagram #Foodie #Delicious #Dessert  #Food #FoodPorn #FoodPho

#Crepes #Eataly #Foodie #Foodgram #Foodstagram #Foodie #Delicious #Dessert #Food #FoodPorn #FoodPhotography #Nutella #FoodPics #Delicious #Sweets #DessertGram #Regram #Repost #NomNom #Hashtag #iPhoneography

  • This spout spits out Nutella. 'Nuff said. #EEEEEATS #DessertGram #Chocolate #Nutella #Delicious #Eat 388719
  • #Crepes #Eataly #Foodie #Foodgram #Foodstagram #Foodie #Delicious #Dessert  #Food #FoodPorn #FoodPho 388720

Eataly NYC

    • 4.0

What do you call a fake noodle? An imPASTA! Surviving the blizzard by whipping together some ingredi

What do you call a fake noodle? An imPASTA! Surviving the blizzard by whipping together some ingredients I bought at eatalyusa (Afeltra #Penne, Lidia's Artichoke Marinara Sauce, #Prosciutto di Parma & freshly grated Pecorino Romano) s

  • What do you call a fake noodle? An imPASTA! Surviving the blizzard by whipping together some ingredi 441310

Marocchino Nutella at Eataly

Eataly officially erected a full time Nutella Bar months ago with all sorts of crepes, cones and croissants just waiting to be filled with that lovely hazelnut spread.  I'm a huge fan of Nutella but I hadn't indulged until this past weekend when I was craving both caffeine and chocolate.  It was the perfect opportunity to try out the Marocchino; an espresso with steamed milk layered with Nutella and a sprinkle of cocoa.

 

Eataly

 

This was very similar to my old favorite Piedmonte from Caffe Lavazza except with a bottom layer of rich, silky Nutella that pretty much put this over the top creating a hot espresso hazelnut shake. I may have a new favorite.

  •  309531

Information of Eataly

Location
200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
Phone Number
(212) 229-2560
Category
Italian / Cafes
Average Price
$20 - $29 | Dinner
Business Hours
Sun:10:00AM - 11:00PM
Mon:10:00AM - 11:00PM
Tue:10:00AM - 11:00PM
Wed:10:00AM - 11:00PM
Thu:10:00AM - 11:00PM
Fri:10:00AM - 11:00PM
Sat:10:00AM - 11:00PM
Occasion
friends / family / date
Dress code
Casual
Reservation
Yes
Wheelchair accessible
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Outdoor dining
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeout
No
Caters
No
Website
Image-thumb_s

Recent editor

love_chat_noir

map

Restaurants Nearby 

ADD YOUR BLOG ARTICLE TO TABELOG

How to?
Here you go! Do you have a review of Eataly on your blog?
By pasting this simple little snippet in to the source of your blog, you can easily and automatically post your restaurant reviews to Tabelog.us!
It will take 1-3 days for your review to appear.
You can also edit your reviews directly from "My Page" on the Tabelog.us site. Now, Rate some restaurants and start building your own personalized restaurant guide!

SMALL

Blog_badge_xxs

MEDIUM

Blog_badge_s

LARGE

Tabelog_badge_general